Exhibit #23 — Noelle DeLa Rosa Goldberg voicemail and Charley email response
Description
STUB — Awaiting source materials. Pending items: voicemail audio file or written transcription of Noelle DeLa Rosa Goldberg (Co-Opposing Counsel)‘s 4/22/2026 voicemail to Charles Nibley (Respondent); copy / PDF of Charley’s reply email sent at 12:09 PM the same day.
On 4/22/2026 Noelle DeLa Rosa Goldberg (Co-Opposing Counsel) left a voicemail for Charles Nibley (Respondent). Charley responded by email at 12:09 PM on 4/22/2026. The exhibit captures both halves of the exchange and Charley’s contemporaneous decision to redirect oral counsel-to-litigant communication into the written record.
Strategic Relevance
Documenting attempted oral channels and Charley’s redirection to writing. A self-represented litigant communicating with opposing counsel benefits from a complete, dateable written record. By replying in writing the same day, Charley preserves both the substance of the contact and the timeline. This exhibit is the predicate for EX24 - 2026-04-22 - Noelle DeLa Rosa Goldberg written response with incorrect notice date — the written response from Noelle that followed contains the November 3, 2025 notice-date misstatement. EX23 and EX24 should be deployed together when the issue is opposing counsel’s accuracy as to the underlying record.
Use cases.
- Minor’s counsel packet: available if questions arise about communications between counsel and Charley during the run-up to the 5/11 hearing.
- 6/1 RFO: potentially relevant if the substance of the voicemail or email touches on a disputed factual representation.
Cross-references
- Related exhibits: EX24 - 2026-04-22 - Noelle DeLa Rosa Goldberg written response with incorrect notice date, EX25 - 2026-04-24 - Meet-and-confer memorialization re Miku concert
- Source file: Awaiting upload — see Description.
Awaiting
- Voicemail audio (m4a / mp3) or verbatim transcription
- PDF / .eml of Charley’s 4/22 12:09 PM reply email
- Subject and substantive content for the Description section once source materials reviewed